Tuesday, April 20, 2010

"In my eyes, it is chauvinistic that a crowd of mostly men needs to pass the time-outs watching young girls dancing and shaking. That seems pretty repulsive to me."


What can bring feminists and Haredim together?  Cheerleaders.

It seems that the club, the fans, and the cheerleaders themselves have tried their best to walk a fine line of modesty, but the truth is that there is no modesty in having young girls parade around in front of men for the entertainment of men. 

And lets be honest here:  most of what passes for "cheerleading" at professional sports venues is usually nothing more than cheesecake.  

I agree that a lot of the high-school and college cheerleading should be considered a sport, as it requires real talent and dedication to perform at that level.  

However, most of the professional sports teams just want cleavage and thighs.
Most "professional cheerleading" is no more a sport than pole-dancing is.

My question is this:  if the club was required to have cheerleaders, and they didn't want to have cheerleaders because of the sensitivities of their audience, why didn't the club choose to use male cheerleaders?

Surely there are some very talented male cheerleaders who would have loved the opportunity to show their talents, they could have given a very good show, and the article doesn't say that the rules required that cheerleaders have to be girls--and young girls at that!

So, it seems that the club is not being entirely honest here.  But, it could just be how the story is written.  

If you want to judge for yourself, check out this video--(Warning--it is not entirely tsniut, as the girls "modest" attire is not that modest, and they also show some clips of the Tel Aviv cheerleaders.) VIDEO

No sexiness, we're Holy City cheerleaders

 A dozen dancing girls hit the hardwood floors of a Jerusalem basketball court on a recent spring night with an unusual goal - show nothing sexy.

These are the Hapoel Jerusalem cheerleaders, and their defiantly flat performances are the result of a long-running saga that has spawned an unlikely alliance of Orthodox Jews and feminists taking on professional sports.

Critics want them off the court and the league will not cave in. The result is a sexless, covered-up performance.

The dispute highlights a frequent problem in the Jewish state, where the  sensitivities of the religious minority clash with the more worldly views of the secular majority, particularly in Jerusalem with its large religious population.

The two worlds are now colliding on a basketball court.

Clad in footless white tights and tops resembling maternity frocks, the cheerleaders dutifully performed their time-out numbers.

They twirled and jumped, but there were none of the gyrating hips, flashes of thigh, glimpses of cleavage or smouldering looks commonly seen in the routines of more famous troupes like the Los Angeles Laker Girls, or even the sensuous dancers of local rivals, Maccabi Tel Aviv.

The row has been on the backburner for more than a year since Israel's top basketball league decreed cheerleaders mandatory for every team.

Some clubs, like Hapoel Jerusalem, objected, saying cheerleaders would offend many of their fans who are observant Orthodox Jews.

The league responded with a "have fun or else..." policy and imposed fines on teams who refused.

Things have come to a head in recent weeks as politicians of different hues have taken up the issue, in what the Israeli media have dubbed "the  coalition against cheerleaders."

"It's a combination of two camps that are often hostile to each other, the religious and the feminists," said lawmaker Uri Orbach of the religious Jewish Home party.

Orbach, who petitioned Sports and Culture Minister Limor Livnat, says he  has nothing against cheerleaders in general, but is opposed to fining clubs that don't want them.

"The reasons are religious ones - the (lack of) modesty bothers many of the fans. When they go to a basketball game, they don't want to see girls in minis dancing," he said.

According to Orthodox Jewish tradition, women are required to dress modestly, covering up their arms to their wrists and legs to the ankles.  They also refrain from wearing trousers or tight clothing.

But Orbach also cited feminist reasons for joining the 19 women's groups  that appealed to Livnat.

"In my eyes, it is chauvinistic that a crowd of mostly men needs to pass  the time-outs watching young girls dancing and shaking. That seems pretty repulsive to me," he said.

At a recent game in Jerusalem, most fans sat impassively as the troupe performed. There were no jeers or catcalls, but many said they would prefer a cheerleader-free environment.

"It is not right that the league administration forces the club to use things that cause unpleasantness for much of the crowd. It is an embarrassment and outrageous," said 19-year-old fan Avishai Slonim.

The cheerleaders say they understand the sensitivities and try to adapt.

"That's why the girls are dressed in long tights, with hair gathered. Their appearance is very respectable. Their movements don't project any sort of sexuality," said Yael Brainess, their trainer and choreographer.

"They do lots of acrobatics and create energy, not through feminine movements, but more through strength," she said, adding that they have received positive feedback from the fans.

However, some say the restricted performances do a disservice to the sport of cheerleading.

"It's a bit primitive for God's sake," said Anna Tarasova, a former Jerusalem cheerleading coach and now head of the Tel Aviv dancers. "The girls need to dance and give a good show."

Following the petitions, Livnat appealed to the league, which agreed to do away with the fines, replacing them with financial incentives for teams that do use cheerleaders.

"She did it from the feminist side of things. She told them it was unacceptable to have fines and girls under the age of 16 performing," said Livnat's spokesman, Ran Lior.

And it appears that the undisclosed bonuses for clubs using cheerleaders  was enough to entice Hapoel Jerusalem to maintain their troupe, even though they publicly disavow any connection.

"They are the cheerleaders of the (league) administration. The moment they stop sending them, we won't have them," said Hapoel spokesman Dan Shoshani.

But that will not be happening any time soon, according to league spokesperson Hagai Segal, who played down Hapoel's objections, saying it  was now voluntary.

"We send them and if they have them, it's a sign that they want them," said Segal, who also brushed off concerns from religious fans.

"In life there are always things you don't like. I don't like it when the fans chant: 'War, war, war,' but what can you do? You can't please every one," he said.

And so it seems Jerusalem's cheerleaders, unloved, unwanted and definitely not sexy, are here to stay. - AFP

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please do not use comments to personally attack other posters.